Plumbing New Standards - Call 1300 307 708

Questions & Answers

All your questions answered, we're here to help..!

Ask a Question
News List

Do Sensor-Activated Taps Save Water?

Asked by Unknown - Unknown

Article by Plumbing Connection Autumn

A new study reveals that sensor activated taps may not save as much water as is believed.


Over the years, there has been much debate among North American water efficiency professionals, manufacturers, green building advocates, and others regarding the water savings associated with using sensor-activated valves (also known as ‘hands-free’ or ‘touch-free’ valves) in restrooms. This includes the three main types of valves found in commercial restrooms, i.e., flush valves for urinals, flush valves for toilets, and flow control valves for tapware (faucets).

While it is commonly accepted that these sensor valves are more hygienic than manually operated valves, there remains some question as to whether or not they are more water efficient.

Because of this uncertainty, our team selected a multi-tenant office tower building in Hillsborough Country, Florida as an ideal candidate to study the ‘real world’ situation. The purpose of the project was to evaluate the effectiveness of sensor-operated valves to save water. The project included a comprehensive pre- and post-auditing program involving physical inspections, sub-metering, data logging, and maintenance staff surveys. It evaluated changes in water demands when manually operated toilet, urinal, and tapware valves were replaced with sensor-operated fixtures. The study was conducted over a 23-month period beginning February 2007 and concluding January 2009.

To help quantify any change to washroom water demands related to the introduction of sensor-activated plumbing fixtures, the project was divided into four phases:

  • Phase 1: pre-monitor water demands of washrooms with existing manually operated fixtures,
  • Phase 2: monitor water demands after manual tapware replaced by sensor activated tapware
  • Phase 3: monitor water demands after manual urinal flush valves replaced by sensor-activated valves, and
  • Phase 4: monitor water demands after manual toilet flush valves replaced by sensor-activated valves.

While the results achieved in this relatively small-scale project many not necessarily be indicative of results that might occur in other projects, they clearly indicate a significant increase in water demands when manually operated plumbing fixtures where converted to sensor-activated ‘touch-free’ models. The total average daily demand of the men’s and ladies’ washrooms almost double from 2,475L to 4,700L per day when all tapware, urinals and toilets were concerted to sensor-activated units.

That there was no decrease in water demands when the flush valve were converted to sensor-operated did not come as a surprise, as one would not expect there to be fewer flushes (most of us have experienced ‘phantom flashes’ with sensor valves, something that is not possible with manual vales). However, the measured increase of 54% in water demands when sensor-activated toilet flush valves were installed was much higher than expected. As for the tapware, water demands increase by 31% when the manual fixtures were replaced by ‘touch-free’ fixtures.

Prior to Hillsborough, two other studies had been performed that also indicated sensor-activated taps in public setting were not water savers.

The first of those studies was conducted by Thames Water Research & Technology in 2000 as the Millennuim Dome in London1. Over the period of one year, tap (faucet) use was measure for 240 taps, including both manual and infrared (sensor-operated) fixtures. Results showed the following:

Average water use per user visit (litres):

Manual – 0.9

Infrared – 1.8

Increase – 100%

The study summarises tap use with this statement: “Surprisingly over the year the conventional swivel top (manual) taps used significantly less water than the purported more efficient types, with each user of the swivel top (manual) taps using, an average, just less than 1 litres of water.”

 


The second study was conducted in 1997-1999 and was directed at photovoltaic water heating2. As part of the analysis, tap use was again measured for one year each for manual and sensor-activated taps. The following results are for taps rated at 8.3L per minute (Lpm):

Average Hot Water Consumption Per Day Per Washroom (litres):

Manual – 372

Infrared – 587

Increase – 58%

Study report for all three projects many be downloaded for our MaP testing website: http://www.map-testing.com/view/reports.html#faucets

Unfortunately, tapware manufacturers in North America continue to claim “touch less” taps save water. The results of the studies referenced above clearly contradict those claims. There is little doubt that automatic sensor-activated taps are not the optimum choice when it comes to water efficiency. However, the question remains: why is the intuitive choice for automatic faucets not necessarily the water-efficient choice? One reason is that ALL automatic censor-activate taps are set to open at their full flow rate (average of 4.6Lpm in the case of the Hillsborough study) while manually-operated taps are typically used at flow rates much less than 3.0Lpm (users rarely fully open manual taps, possible to avoid splashing).

It should be noted that the US national standard for tapware installed in commercial installations (such as in the Hillsborough building) sets a minimum flow rate of 1.9Lpm. Other studies have shown that is both manual and sensor-activated taps are fitted with 1.9Lpm flow regulators, water use will be virtually the same. A disadvantage of the maximum 1.9Lpm flow rate for commercial installations, however, is the likelihood that hot water will never arrive at the tap in more circumstances.

In conclusion, we recommend that manufacturers of sensor-activated valves and taps promote these fixtures based upon their true attributes, hygiene and touch-free convenience, rather than fictitious water use efficiency claims.
Article written by John Koeller, P.Eng. and William Gauley, P.Eng.

1Thames Water Research & Technology, 2002. The Millennium Dome “Watercycle” experiment: to evaluate water efficiency and customer perception at a recycling scheme for 6 million visitors.

2ASHRAE, 2002. Field Test of a Photovoltaic Water Heater, Report No. HI-02-8-3

Answered by Mike McEntee

Topics: • Commercial  • Domestic  

I'm trying to get the old tap assembly apart to change out the o ring and plunger, the tap i very old its brand is raymor, i cannot get a grip on the shaft to unscrew it, there is only a round part with a tab on it but is recessed in the wall, is there any thing i can MacGyver up to unscrew it?

Asked by Ken - Port Macquarie

Hi Ken,

The best way might be to try a spark plug socket set or similar in order to grip the base of the spindle.

Answered by Mike McEntee

Topics: • Commercial  

I have repaired my hot water pipes in the bathroom with press on fittings. after many tries I manage to stop the connections from leaking. My question is why have I lost hot water pressure only at the shower, the kitchen pressure is good?

Asked by Shaun - Latrobe

Hi Shaun,

You may need to check the filter in the shower rose as that may be semi blocked.

Answered by Mike McEntee

Topics: • Domestic  

What would you say is the equivalent of 100mm, 90mm and 65mm PVC DWV in the USA? Regards Kyle

Asked by Kyle - Gold Coast

Hi Kyle,
In the USA pipe sizing is generally sized in imperial measurements.
100mm is 4” inch, 65mm is 2.5” inch and generally 90mm or 80mm is referred to as being 3” inch.
Hydrmet have a web site which may help.

Answered by Mike McEntee

Topics:

I have a specialised tap that the plumber can't fix the dripping. He wants to replace it but can't remove the tap as it is glued into the glass top of the vanity and the glass shelf is siliconed in. He says he has to remove the glass shelf in order to get a go at removing the tap. He thinks he will break the glass. Do you have any suggestions?

Asked by Vivienne - Maroubra

Hi Vivienne

Unfortunately after viewing the photo and the way the basin tap is installed, it seems that the only way of disconnecting the tap would be to remove the glass shelf.

It is difficult to say without being on site, but it does seem as though there is no other way.

We are an Adelaide based business, so unfortunately won’t be able to help any further.

 

Kind regards

Paul McEntee

Answered by Paul McEntee

Topics: • Domestic  

Hi, we've got an outlet at the side of the house that has been overflowing. The foul smell and contents suggest its sewerage. We've since realised when we use the kitchen tap it causes it to overflow, nothing happens from bathroom toilets basins and when we use a mop handle to try to clear any blockages in the outlet it bubbles and spurts out the foul water out of the kitchen sink with force. We've poured in a bottle of drano over 2 days, into the outside pipe, and pouring large quantities of an enzyme down both over another 3 days and it's not much better. Should I be looking at a plumber to clear it, and should it be connected to the outside outlet? Thanks

Asked by Elaine - Gunn NT

Hi Elaine,
It sounds like you have an overflow relief gully that is overflowing due to a blockage with in the sewer waste pipe, this will happen in order to protect overflowing inside.
We are a Adelaide based company and you will need contact a plumber to clear the blockage.

Answered by Mike McEntee

Topics: • Domestic  

 1 2 3 >  Last ›

Recent Posts

Categories

Our Services

Our Services

We deliver first class plumbing services, products and installation services for gas fitting and hot water services. We guarantee it and wont plumb it any other way.

read more

Book a Plumber Online

Book a Plumber Online

We want to give our customers convenience and options, so book your plumbing job online, request a quote, email us or call now.

book now

Hints & Tips

Hints & Tips

Water is one of our most precious resources. It is highly important and a challenge to know how we can make the most of it. Read our hints and tips on water saving and plumbing.

read more

Request a Quote Online

Request a Quote Online

We prefer to give you a quote for your plumbing needs so there are no surprises and you are aware of what the job exactly involves. Request your FREE quote today.

request now